IN THE LAST FEW POSTS I've been exploring how a propaganda email first establishes, and then develops, it's conflated categories.
At the end of the the previous post, the conflated picture had been expanded to this:
|
The Categories Implied by the Email: |
The Real World: | |
| Them (liberals): | Us (conservatives): | (not so simple) |
| They hate our troops. | We love and respect our troops. | Liberals love and respect our troops, too. |
| They think our troops torture Iraqis. | We don't think our troops torture Iraqis. | A few of our troops, acting in accord with orders from above, did torture some Iraqis. (Pictures, remember?) |
| They blame the troops for the torture and abuse. | We support our troops, instead of blaming them. | Conservatives are the ones who throw all the blame on the troops. Liberals blame the Bush administration. |
| They are athiests. | We believe in God. | Actually there are many liberal believers, and many conservative atheists. |
| They are anti-American. | We are patriotic. | And, of course, liberals are just a patriotic as conservatives. |
The email doesn't stop there, however.
There's a little emblem, at this point, to one side, declaring "God Bless Our Troops":

Notice how the emblem ties patriotism, the troops, love, and religion all together in a neat little package.
The net effect of all this is to set up two equations:
Us = People who appreciated those pictures = loving people = people who don't believe we tortured Iraqis = conservatives = troop supporters = religious believers = patriots = the good guys.
Them = People who would hate those pictures = unloving people = people who believe we tortured Iraqis = liberals = troop despisers = atheists = Unamerican = the bad guys.
The email now announces for the first time that it is a "prayer wheel" for our soldiers, and asks you to say a prayer and then forward it to the people in your address book.
This is very clever. If you really are one of the "good guys" how could you break a prayer chain for our troops?
The email doesn't mention the fact that by forwarding it, you will not only be encouraging your friends to support the troops, but also be disseminating a whole series of lies and brainwashing.
There are three remaining touches, however, before the deceptions are finished.
The first is a little homage to the American flag, surrounded by a list of wars:

Once again, the point is conflation. First, to conflate the idea of war with the idea of patriotism. Apparently the flag can't wave "PROUDLY for our FREEDOM" in peacetime.
The second function is to conflate the six wars listed into one concept. Notice that WWII, the war that is easiest to justify and the one most people approve of, is at the top in order to set the tone.
The three wars which there is a great deal of debate over in this country are at the bottom, where they can bask in that tone. The whole idea is to cement the reader's approval of our policy in WWII to our quite different policy in Iraq.
The subtext is to put anyone who would question our invasion of Iraq in the same light as someone who would have sided with Hitler.
So the implied world-view has been modified again:
|
The Categories Implied by the Email: |
The Real World: | |
| Them (liberals): | Us (conservatives): | (not so simple) |
| They hate our troops. | We love and respect our troops. | Liberals love and respect our troops, too. |
| They think our troops torture Iraqis. | We don't think our troops torture Iraqis. | A few of our troops, acting in accord with orders from above, did torture some Iraqis. (Pictures, remember?) |
| They blame the troops for the torture and abuse. | We support our troops, instead of blaming them. | Conservatives are the ones who throw all the blame on the troops. Liberals blame the Bush administration. |
| They are athiests. | We believe in God. | Actually there are many liberal believers, and many conservative atheists. |
| They are anti-American. | We are patriotic. | Liberals are just a patriotic as conservatives. |
| They think you can separate belief in God from love and patriotism and support of the troops. | We understand that belief in God, patriotism, love, and support of the troops are all the same thing. | There really is a difference between your religion, your country, and your capacity for love. |
| They disrespect our fight against fascism in WWII. | We understand that any war the United States gets involved in is, by definition, a noble cause. | It's possible that one war is a noble cause and another is a mistake, even when the country, as a whole, means well. |
The world is getting divided pretty firmly here, but the email isn't done. There are two more touches to come.
And one of those is the most frightening yet...
- Ken Watts's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- Email this page
- Delicious
- Digg
- StumbleUpon
- Yahoo






Recent comments
2 weeks 1 day ago
2 weeks 1 day ago
3 weeks 1 day ago
8 weeks 5 hours ago
8 weeks 5 hours ago
9 weeks 5 days ago
9 weeks 5 days ago
10 weeks 3 days ago
10 weeks 6 days ago
11 weeks 1 day ago